March 6, 2007
Jared Cotter

Randy: "You gave a solid performance. It actually was good."
Paula: "I think you need to work on coloring up the way you sing."
Simon: "It wasn't very original. This one (performance) gets lost in the mix. This was not the wow factor."
Phil Stacey

Randy: "The high notes are great. Work on the low register. It was alright."
Paula: "I don't feel this was your best performance."
Simon: "I didn't get that. It was a very strange choice of song."
Sanjaya Malakar

Randy: "You haven't returned to form since then (when we first saw you)."
Paula: "I would continue to tell you to try to get out of your comfort zone."
Simon: "The good news is that it wasn't as gastly as last week."
Sundance Head

Randy: "That was kind of hot right there."
Paula: "Midway through you really kicked into your Sundance groove."
Simon: "I thought you lost your charm this week. Very generic bar singer."
Blake Lewis

Randy: "That was hot dude. I loved it."
Paula: "I didn't know the song but I was interested."
Simon: "You stand out. You will 100 percent be here next week."
Brandon Rogers

Randy: "It was a solid performance."
Paula: "I thought it was pretty phenomonal."
Simon: "I don't think you presented yourself very well in this stage of the competition because I had high hopes for you because you're one of the better singers."
Chris Richardson

Randy: "Every week you come out here and put the boys on blast."
Paula: "You adapted well. You picked a great song."
Simon: "It was good. It's not the best vocal we've heard."
Chris Sligh

Randy: "You get the vote for prize of the night."
Paula: "It wasn't my favorite performance."
Simon: "You've got potential. A lot of potential."