American Idol Season 6 - Girls Night

February 28, 2007


Leslie Hunt - "Feelin' Good"
Randy: "It was definitely a little bit on the pitchy side. It was just alright for me."
Paula: "You're being you. You're back in your element."
Simon: "I think you're getting a little bit lost in this performance."


Melinda Doolittle - "My Funny Valentine"
Randy: "Melinda Doolittle came out here tonight to win it. You made the mark tonight."
Paula: "To me that was just astounding."
Simon: "That was incredible. Really."


LaKisha Jones - "Midnight Train to Georgia"
Randy: "That was hot."
Paula: "I loved it."
Simon: "You are a phenomonally good singer. I don't think it was as good as last week."


Sabrina Sloan - "All The Man That I Need"
Randy: "Very nice one overall."
Paula: "You are fantastic."
Simon: "Very good. Don't confuse power with shouting though."



Stephanie Edwards - "Dangerously In Love"
Randy: "You proved that you should be up here."
Paula: "I think you were fantastic."
Simon: "I have to agree with Paula. You're not just taking part in this competition. You're coming out here again putting your mark down. I thought it was a terrific performance."

Alaina Alexander - "Not Ready to Make Nice"
Randy: "It was a mess for me. It was all over the place."
Paula: "The pitch was a little bit off."
Simon: "It was like Randy taking part in a 100 meter sprint. You ran out of steam three quarters of the way."


Antonella Barba - "Because You Loved Me"
Randy: "Pitch was all over the place. That didn't work."
Paula: "I think you made leaps and bounds from last week."
Simon: "I thought you were worse than last week."



Gina Glocksen - "Alone"
Randy: "This song was a good song choice for you - it's where you really belong."
Paula: "Excellent job. Really good."
Simon: "I thought your vocals felt very forced at the end."


Haley Scarnato - "Queen of the Night"
Randy: "It wasn't great for me. Vocally it wasn't on point."
Paula: "I think you were so much better this week."
Simon: "I think it was A for effort. Vocally you came out bad on that."



Jordin Sparks - "Reflection"
Randy: "What you are today is just unbelievable to me as a record producer."
Paula: "You are one brilliant talented girl."
Simon: "It wasn't your best but compared to a lot of other people, it was excellent."